TypedFactory reloaded

Another piece of code that I wrote some time ago came back to my attention recently and I decided to give it the same treatment as the SmartConstructor and do some cleanup on the TypedFactory port I did for Unity.

One thing I really disliked at the time was that the Unity Interception Extension cannot generate a “proxy without target” out of the box. If you want to intercept calls to an object you actually need to have that object. A pipeline with no target isn’t possible with Unity.

As I had experimented with IL code generation before I took the long way round and built a NullObject generator. Not pretty. But it worked.

Another issue was the need to fumble an instance of the container into the interception pipeline by putting it in a dictionary, retrieving it down the pipeline, cast it back to a container and then start working with it. For the life of me I couldn’t find an architecturally clean way to solve that issue then. But the ugly one worked.

If you can’t see the forest for the trees you need to take a step back. A year later I took a look at a post that I had read back then and all of a sudden the pieces fell into place.

As an answer to a question in the Unity discussion forum Chris Tavares solved both of my problems. I just didn’t get it the first time.

The code snippet to generate a proxy without a target (or more precisely an interception pipeline without a target) is really simple.

Intercept.NewInstanceWithAdditionalInterfaces(
  Type type,
  ITypeInterceptor interceptor,
  IEnumerable<IInterceptionBehavior> interceptionBehaviors,
  IEnumerable<Type> additionalInterfaces,
  params object[] constructorParameters)

 

This method gives us all that we need. The type parameter lets you specify the type of the target object. As we don’t actually need a target typeof(object) is good enough. The VirtualMethodInterceptor from Chris’ answer is what we will use as interceptor. The factory interface we want to implement goes into the additionalInterfaces. As our target is a simple object we don’t need to bother about constructorParameters.

The actual factory logic is implemented as an IInterceptionBehavior called FactoryBehavior (I’m all for self-explanatory names by the way). But that behavior still needs an instance of the container which is just not available at the place this is all wired up.

Again, Chris’ post gave me a solution that I just didn’t recognize.

Anyway, to hook it up to the container, the quickest thing to do would be to use InjectionFactory to call the Intercept.NewInstance API.

InjectionFactory is derived from InjectionMember (as is TypedFactory). InjectionMembers are Unity’s way to make very specific additions to the build pipeline of a type. An InjectionFactory tells the  container how to construct an object instead of letting the container figure out how to do that itself.

InjectionFactory has two constructors that each take a delegate that lets you specify how to create your object of interest.

I’ll just show you the signature of the greedier one of the two.

public InjectionFactory(Func<IUnityContainer, Type, string, object> factoryFunc)

The first parameter is a container out of the depths of the Unity infrastructure. And its totally for free. Below you see the new implementation of the AddPolicies(Type, Type, string, IPolicyList) method of the TypedFactory.

public override void AddPolicies(Type ignore, Type factoryType, string name, IPolicyList policies)
{
  if (factoryType.IsInterface)
  {
    InjectionFactory injectionFactory = new InjectionFactory(
      (container, t, n) => Intercept.NewInstanceWithAdditionalInterfaces(
        typeof(object),
        new VirtualMethodInterceptor(),
        new IInterceptionBehavior[] { new FactoryBehavior(container, this.selector) },
        new[] { factoryType }));

    injectionFactory.AddPolicies(ignore, factoryType, name, policies);
  }
  else if (factoryType.IsAbstract)
  {
    InjectionFactory injectionFactory = new InjectionFactory(
      (container, t, n) => Intercept.NewInstance(
        factoryType,
        new VirtualMethodInterceptor(),
        new IInterceptionBehavior[] { new FactoryBehavior(container, this.selector) }));

    injectionFactory.AddPolicies(ignore, factoryType, name, policies);
  }
  else
  {
    throw new ArgumentException("'factoryType' must either be an interface or an abstract class.", "factoryType");
  }
}

It supports interfaces and abstract classes as factoryType. Based on that distinction we either use the Intercept.NewInstanceWithAdditionalInterfaces or Intercept.NewInstance method to create our factory implementation. The container provided by the InjectionFactory gets forwarded into our FactoryBehavior and we are done. The rest of the implementation stays the same.

Now this is more like it. We reuse large parts of the Unity infrastructure instead of reinventing the wheel and quite a bit of code becomes obsolete. As usual you can find the code for the updated TypedFactory on my CodePlex site (project TecX.Unity[Factories] and the tests that show how it works under TecX.Unity.Test[Factories]).

Auto-generated Factories with Unity

If you need to create objects after the initialization of your object graph by the container injecting factories is the way to go.

But defining factory interfaces and/or abstract base classes, implementing them and duplicating the knowledge your container already has does not make sense. For these scenarios Castle Windsor has it’s Typed Factory Facilities.

Define just the factory interface. Register it with the container and tell the container to generate an implementation for you. After all the implementation does not matter. Its a detail the consumers should not have to care about. If you need to forward runtime parameters like ConnectionStrings or file names the container takes care of that too.

With TecX.Unity.Factories you get the same set of features for Unity as well. All of a sudden using factories becomes as easy as this:

public interface IMyFactory
{
 IFoo Create(string name);
}
public interface IFoo
{
 string Name { get; }
}
public class Foo : IFoo
{
 public string Name { get; set; }
 public Foo(string name)
 {
 this.Name = name;
 }
}
var container = new UnityContainer();
container.RegisterType<IMyFactory>(new TypedFactory());
container.RegisterType<IFoo, Foo>();
var factory = container.Resolve<IMyFactory>();
var foo = factory.Create("some name");
Assert.AreEqual("some name", foo.Name);

This also works for property injection as long as you mark the property for injection by the container.

container.RegisterType<IFoo, Foo>(new InjectionProperty("Name"));

After a major overhaul of its internals the TypedFactory no longer relies on Castle DynamicProxy for the generation of the interface implementation. Unity brings its own powerful block for interception. It just insists that there has to be a target object for the interception pipeline. After integrating the technique used to generate lazy proxies auto-generating factories is now a Unity-only implementation.

Get the source code for the factory generation here (project TecX.Unity folder Factories and the test suite that shows how to use it in TecX.Unity.Factories.Test).